Friday, November 13, 2009

Revised Draft Language

Be it enacted by the General Assembly of Virginia:
1. That §§ 32.1122.7 and 32.1122.21 of the Code of Virginia are amended and reenacted and that the Code of Virginia is amended by adding a section numbered 32.1122.7:1 as follows:

§ 32.1122.7. Virginia Health Workforce Development Authority. purpose; Board of Directors.
A. There is hereby created as a public body corporate and as a political subdivision of the
Commonwealth the Virginia Health Workforce Development Authority, with such public and corporate powers as are set forth in § 32.1122.7: 1. The Authority is hereby constituted a public instrumentality, exercising public and essential governmental functions with the power and purpose to provide for the health, welfare, convenience, knowledge, benefit, and prosperity of the residents of the Commonwealth and such other persons who might be served by the Authority. The Authority is being established to move the Commonwealth forward in achieving its vision of ensuring a quality health workforce for all Virginians.

The mission of the Authority is to facilitate the development of a statewide health professions pipeline that identifies, educates, recruits and retains a diverse, appropriately geographically distributed and culturally-competent quality workforce. The mission of the Authority is accomplished by: (i) providing the statewide infrastructure required for health workforce needs assessment and planning that maintains engagement by health professions training programs in decision-making and program implementation; (ii) serving as the advisory board and setting priorities for the Virginia Area Health Education Center (AHEC) Program; (iii) coordinating with and serving as a resource to relevant state, regional and local entities; including the Department of Health Professions Workforce Data Center, JLARC, and the Joint Commission on Health Care, the Southwest Virginia Graduate Medical Education Consortium, the Southwest Virginia Health Authority or any similar regional Health Authority that may in the future be developed and legislatively authorized; (iv) informing state and local policy development as it pertains to health care delivery, training and education; (v) identifying and promoting evidence based strategies for health workforce pipeline development and interdisciplinary health care service models, particularly those affecting rural and other underserved areas; (vi) supporting communities in their health workforce recruitment and retention efforts, and developing partnerships and promoting models of participatory engagement with businesses and community-based and social organizations to foster the integration of health care training and education; (vii) advocating for programs that will result in reducing the debt-load of newly trained health professionals; (viii) identifying high priority target areas within each region of the Commonwealth and working toward health workforce development initiatives that improve health measurably in those areas; and (ix) fostering or creating innovative health workforce development models that provide both health and economic benefits to the regions they serve.

B. The Authority shall be governed by a Board of Directors. The Commissioner of Health, with the assistance of recommendations from the Health Workforce Advisory Committee, shall appoint the Inaugural Board of Directors within three months of the enactment of this legislation. The composition of the Inaugural Board shall accurately reflect the geographic, racial and ethnic diversity found within the Commonwealth to the extent possible, with an emphasis on those areas and populations that are underserved and under-represented. Members of the Inaugural Board of Directors shall serve as the chair of a subcommittee comprised of stakeholders of their respective sectors and shall be responsible for obtaining input and representing the members of their sector during their term in Office. The Inaugural Board shall establish by-laws for the Authority within six months of their appointment. The by-laws should ensure continuity of representation by all sectors as reflected by the composition of the Inaugural Board.

The Inaugural Board shall be comprised of twenty (20) members and two ad hoc members, each representing a particular sector of the workforce pipeline. These include:

Health Professions Education Sector
• Dean from a dental school located in Virginia, or executive level designee – representing oral health
• Dean from an allopathic medical school located in Virginia, or executive level designee – representing allopathic training programs and physicians
• Dean from an osteopathic medical school located in Virginia, or executive level designee – representing osteopathic training programs and physicians
• Dean from a mid-level training program located in Virginia, or executive designee – representing mid-level health professionals
• Department Chair or designee in an educational institution located in Virginia that trains mental health professionals – representing mental health professionals
• Dean from a school of pharmacy located in Virginia, or executive level designee – representing pharmacy
• Dean from a school of nursing located in Virginia, or executive level designee – representing nursing
• Dean from a school of allied health located in Virginia, or executive level designee – representing allied health professions such as health administration, HIT, OT, PT
• Chancellor of the Virginia Community College System, or executive level designee – representing all other allied and ancillary health professions represented by the community college system such as laboratory techs, EMTs, office/admin support.

Health Facilities and Employer Sector
• A representative from a mental health agency or facility in an underserved area – representing community mental health
• A hospital industry representative from an underserved area – representing health facilities
• A representative from the Virginia Community Healthcare Association, or designee – representing the healthcare safety net
• A representative from a provider association (e.g., AAFP, AAP, VDA, VPHA, VOMA, MSV ) – representing the health professions industry

Community and Community Health Sector
• A representative appointed by the Board of the Older Dominion Partnership who has health or health care expertise - representing the needs of the aging population
• A representative from the Virginia Consortium for Health Philanthropy – representing health philanthropies
• An AHEC Center director or designee – representing the AHECs
• The Executive Director of the Virginia Rural Health Association or designee – representing rural health
• The Commissioner of Health or designee – representing public health and State agencies
• The Director of the Department of Health Professions or designee – representing the regulatory Boards and the Healthcare Workforce Data Center
• One citizen representative from an underserved area

Ad Hoc Members
• One advisory member of the Senate to be appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules;
• One advisory member of the House of Delegates to be appointed by the Speaker of the House of Delegates

§ 32.1122.7:1. Powers and duties of the Virginia Health Workforce Development Authority.
A. The Authority is authorized to serve as the incorporated Consortium of allopathic and osteopathic medical schools in Virginia as required by federal statute to qualify for the receipt of Area Health Education Center funding from the Health Resources and Services Administration Area Health Education Centers programs, legislatively mandated under the Public Health Service Act as amended, Title VII, Section 751, and (42 U.S.C. 294a); and to administer federal, state, and local programs as needed to carry out its public purpose and objectives. The Authority is further authorized to exercise independently the powers conferred by this section in furtherance of its corporate and public purposes,to benefit citizens and such other persons who might be served by the Authority.

B. The Authority is authorized to monitor, collect and track data pertaining to health care delivery, training and education from Virginia educational institutions and other entities as needed to carry out its public purpose and objectives in areas where such data efforts do not already exist.

C. The Authority shall have the authority to assess policies, engage in policy development and make policy recommendations.

D. The Authority shall have the authority to apply for and accept Federal, State and local (public and private) grants, loans, appropriations and donations; hire and compensate staff, including an Executive Director; rent, lease, buy, own, acquire and dispose of property, real or personal; participate in joint ventures, including to make contracts and other agreements, with public and private entities in order to carry out its public purpose and objectives; and make bylaws for the management and regulation of its affairs.

E. The Board of Directors shall report biennially the activities and recommendations of the Authority to the Secretary of Health and Human Resources, Secretary of Education, Secretary of Commerce and Trade, the State Board of Health, the Commissioner of Health, the State Council of Higher Education for Virginia, the Governor, the Joint Commission on Health Care and the General Assembly. In any reporting period where state general funds are appropriated to the Authority, the annual report shall include a detailed summary of how state general funds appropriated to the Authority were expended.

F. The Authority shall be exempt from the Personnel Act, Workforce Transition Act, Administrative Process Act, and Public Procurement Act. The provisions of Chapter 29 (§ 2.2-2900 et seq.) of Title 2.2, Chapter 32 (§ 2.2-3200 et seq.) of Title 2.2, Chapter 40 (§ 2.2-4000 et seq.) of Title 2.2, and Chapter 43 (§ 2.2-4300 et seq.) of Title 2.2 shall not apply to the Authority in the exercise of any power conferred under this chapter.

G. Exemption from taxes or assessments. The exercise of the powers granted by this article shall be in all respects for the benefit of the people of the Commonwealth, for the increase of their commerce and prosperity, and for the improvement of their health and living conditions, and as the operation and maintenance of projects by the Authority and the undertaking of activities in furtherance of the purpose of the Authority constitute the performance of essential governmental functions, the Authority shall not be required to pay any taxes or assessments upon any project or any property acquired or used by the Authority under the provisions of this article or upon the income therefrom, including sales and use taxes on tangible personal property used in the operations of the Authority. The exemption granted in this section shall not be construed to extend to persons conducting, on the premises of the facility, businesses for which local or state taxes would otherwise be required.

H. Exemption from VITA. (specific language to be determined).

§ 32.1122.21. Health Workforce Advisory Committee.
The Commissioner shall establish a Health Workforce Advisory Committee to advise him on all
aspects of the Department’s health workforce duties and responsibilities identified in this article. The
Health Workforce Advisory Committee shall include representatives of (i) each of the Commonwealth’s
academic health centers; (ii) the Statewide Area Health Education Center (AHEC) Program Healthcare
Workforce Authority; (iii) the Virginia Primary Care Association; (iv) the Virginia Health Care
Foundation; (v) the Virginia Association of Free Clinics; (vi) the Virginia Association of Nurse
Executives; (vii) health care providers; (viii) health professions residents and students; and (ix) other
organizations as deemed appropriate by the Commissioner. The Health Workforce Advisory Committee shall be dissolved upon appointment of the Board of Directors for the Authority.

Here is the final draft of all the recommended language based on input obtained to date.  Please keep in mind that legislative services will take this and morph it so wordsmithing isn’t necessary.  My main concern at this point is the size of the Inaugural Board.  Twenty members is larger than what is generally recommended for an effective and efficient Board structure. Ideally, a Board has between 12 - 15 members.  Please keep in mind that each representative is expected to be the spokesperson for a subcommittee.  The subcommittee could and would have broad representation from any/all interested stakeholders.  I welcome suggestions/recommendations for consolidating several of these Board seats if possible.  Thanks again for your engagement in this process!

6 comments:

  1. A couple of ideas...

    I also think 20 is a huge group, but would envision this group electing an executive committee who would be responsible for major decisions and gathering grant info for application and dissemination. I would envision the exec committee as several members of the academic centers group plus one member of the community and one member of the Health facilities group, along with the AHEC staff. The Health facilities and the Community reps can disseminate information to the others in their group.

    Just a thought...could be put together differently, but to have the 20 vote on a Exec committee would make the deciding group less unruly!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have never seen a Board where every member runs a subcommittee - if these are staffed (minutes, refreshments, mailinghs, reports produced, etc) I would guess you need to add one additional staff member for every 15 subcommittee meetings you will be having each year.

    Anther option would be to create committees for physicians, nursing, dental, behavioral health, health public/preventive health, and a couple more.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for working through all of this in such an open manner. Much improved product.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The size of this board is too large. There needs to be some constraint here. Is there really a need for an allopathic and an osteopathic medical school representation? Just have the key players at the table and have FULL representation on the sub committees. My recommendations are highlighted below:

    Health Professions Education Sector
    • Dean from a dental school located in Virginia, or executive level designee – representing oral health
    • Dean from a medical school located in Virginia, or executive level designee
    • Dean from a mid-level training program located in Virginia, or executive designee – assume this is for PAs and NPs predominantly - can they not be represented by a nursing school Dean that has such a program?
    • Department Chair or designee in an educational institution located in Virginia that trains mental health professionals – make this a dean of Social work or Psychology
    • Dean from a school of pharmacy located in Virginia, or executive level designee – representing pharmacy
    • Dean from a school of nursing located in Virginia, or executive level designee – representing nursing
    • Dean from a school of allied health located in Virginia, or executive level designee – representing allied health professions such as health administration, HIT, OT, PT
    • Chancellor of the Virginia Community College System, or executive level designee – representing allied health professions such as health administration, HIT, OT, PT, EMTs - can the Allied health Dean not represent these folks? I think they can and should.

    Health Facilities and Employer Sector
    • A representative from a mental health agency or facility in an underserved area – representing community mental health
    • A hospital industry representative from an underserved area – representing health facilities
    • A representative from the Virginia Community Healthcare Association, or designee – representing the healthcare safety net
    • A representative from a provider association (e.g., AAFP, AAP, VDA, VPHA, VOMA, MSV ) – representing the health professions industry

    Community and Community Health Sector
    • A representative appointed by the Board of the Older Dominion Partnership who has health or health care expertise - representing the needs of the aging population
    • A representative from the Virginia Consortium for Health Philanthropy – representing health philanthropies. Do you really need this group holding a seat at the table? Can they be combined with the seat above that is now designated for elderly to represent community special needs populations. This way you can have full representation at a committee level and one spokes person on this board.
    • An AHEC Center director or designee – representing the AHECs
    • The Executive Director of the Virginia Rural Health Association or designee – representing rural health
    • The Commissioner of Health or designee – representing public health and State agencies. Make this an ex-officio position and thus it decreases the numbers around the table at least from a voting perspective.
    • The Director of the Department of Health Professions or designee – representing the regulatory Boards and the Healthcare Workforce Data Center Make this an ex-officio position and thus it decreases the numbers around the table at least from a voting perspective.

    • One citizen representative from an underserved area

    Ad Hoc Members
    • One advisory member of the Senate to be appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules;
    • One advisory member of the House of Delegates to be appointed by the Speaker of the House of Delegates

    ReplyDelete
  5. The larger size Board is better for this particular situation as you have more stakeholders engaged. This size of Board has worked effectively in other instances, for example, the One Care Consortium has a Board of 30 members.

    ReplyDelete

Please give us your feedback!